Home - Writing - Hal and Dee at the Movies

Mail Hal C F Astell - Site Map

Our Big Differences

Dee and I have such similar tastes in film that our ratings are rarely that different. Here are the few movies that saw our differences in rating amount to more than a single point.


Rating System | 1 - Abysmal | 2 - Bad | 3 - Poor | 4 - OK | 5 - Good | 6 - Excellent | 7 - Classic


Six Point Difference

Title

Year

H

D

Director

Pink Flamingos

1972

7

1

John Waters


Four Point Difference

Title

Year

H

D

Director

Red Dragon

2002

2

6

Brett Ratner


Three Point Difference

Title

Year

H

D

Director

Battlefield Earth

2000

1

4

Roger Christian

The Boondock Saints

1999

2

5

Troy Duffy

The Cowboy and the Frenchman

1988

3

6

David Lynch

The Devil With Hitler

1942

3

6

Alexander Witt

The Incredibly Strange Creatures Who Stopped Living and Became Mixed-Up Zombies!!?

1964

4

1

Ray Dennis Steckler

Resident Evil: Apocalypse

2004

2

5

Alexander Witt

Simon Sez

1999

2

5

Kevin Elders

Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny

2006

1

4

Liam Lynch


Two Point Difference

Title

Year

H

D

Director

Action in the North Atlantic

1943

5

7

Lloyd Bacon

Aphrodisiac!: The Sexual Secret of Marijuana

1971

1

3

Dennis Van Zak

Braindead

1992

7

5

Peter Jackson

Cat Ballou

1965

5

7

Elliot Silverstein

Chungking Express

1994

6

4

Wong Kar Wai

The Covenant

2006

2

4

Renny Harlin

The Curse of the Cat People

1944

7

5

Gunther von Fritsch & Robert Wise

Dawn of the Dead

1978

7

5

George A Romero

Do the Right Thing

1989

7

5

Spike Lee

Electra Glide in Blue

1973

7

5

James William Guercio

Escape from LA

1996

3

5

John Carpenter

The Hatchet Man

1932

5

3

William E Wellman

The Hottest Show in Town

1973

3

1

Eberhard & Phyllis Kronhausen

I'm All Right, Jack

1959

7

5

John Boulting

Island of Lost Souls

1933

7

5

Erle C Kenton

Keeper of the Flame

1942

4

6

George Cukor

Lady and the Tramp

1955

5

7

Clyde Geronimi et al

The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

2003

4

6

Stephen Norrington

Leprechaun 2

1994

2

4

Rodman Flender

Marihuana

1936

2

4

Dwain Esper

Once Upon a Time in Mexico

2003

3

5

Robert Rodriguez

Paris - When It Sizzles

1964

3

5

Richard Quine

Princess Nicotine

1909

5

7

J Stuart Blackton

Revelation Nine

2007

2

4

Vance Null

Santa Sangre

1989

7

5

Alejandro Jodorowsky

Sh! The Octopus

1937

5

7

William McGann

Sinbad the Sailor

1947

5

7

Richard Wallace

The Sitter

?

3

5

Angel Ruiz

Skin Deep

2008

5

3

Erasmus P Romero III

The Texas Chain Saw Massacre

1974

7

5

Tobe Hooper

Tower of London

1962

2

4

Roger Corman

Witchfinder General

1968

6

4

Michael Reeves


Last updated: 9 Sep 2008


Home - Writing - Hal and Dee at the Movies

Mail Hal C F Astell - Site Map